Customer Reviews

Read what some of our satisfied insurance customers have to say about Wagner Insurance! If you’d like to provide your feedback, please submit your online review.

  • Connor Byrne
    Top tier customer service and a genuinely great staff.
  • Alicia Pizza
    Trust them with ALL of my personal and business insurance.Read Full Review

    “Fantastic customer service, extremely knowledgeable, trust them with ALL of my personal and business insurance.”

  • Steven J. Lutz
    Highly recommended!Read Full Review

    “Dave and Mike are great guys. They saved me over 10% off what I was paying for my business insurance with my last agent. I appreciate that I can always get one of them by way of phone or email whenever I have a question or need. Highly recommended!

  • AG
    Their rates are great and they are easy to work with.Read Full Review

    “With so many Insurance Agents in Mercer County NJ it was difficult to decide which insurer to use. Based on many referrals we decided on Wagner Insurance because of their many coverage options (home, car, business issuance). Their rates are great and they are easy to work with.”

  • SN
    A Company that responded very quickly to my auto and home policies.Read Full Review

    “A Company that responded very quickly to my auto and home policies, just prior to my renewal. They offered me a range of Products and solutions that I was able to select from.”

  • FS
    I've been with Wagner insurance since 1977.Read Full Review

    “I’ve been with Wagner insurance since 1977. My parents were with Wagner before I was born (1960). The Wagner’s are very nice people. I’m glad Dave Wagner is continuing the business. ”

  • Chris Tozzi
    Wagner Insurance has always offered my family the most competitive prices.Read Full Review

    “Wagner Insurance has always offered my family the most competitive prices but more importantly, explained to me thoroughly the type of coverages I was entitled. The warm friendly staff and convenient location makes you feel good about going local for you insurance.”