Quotes From Multiple Companies

  • All Risks
  • American Modern Insurance
  • Appalachian Underwriters
  • Applied Underwriters
  • Berkshire Hathaway Guard
  • Burns and Wilcox
  • Chubb Group
  • Coastal Agents Alliance
  • Foremost Insurance
  • Franklin Homeowners Assurance
  • Good2Go Auto Insurance
  • Grundy
  • Hagerty Insurance
  • Harleysville Insurance
  • Hull and Company
  • J.C. Taylor
  • Mercury Insurance
  • MetLife Home and Auto
  • Nationwide Insurance
  • Omni
  • Orchid
  • Patriot National
  • Personal Service Insurance
  • Plymouth Rock Assurance
  • Progressive Insurance
  • RLI Surety
  • Tokio Marine Management
  • Travelers Insurance
  • US Assure
  • United States Liability Insurance
  • Utica First Insurance
  • Vacant Express
  • Wright Flood
  • Connor Byrne
    Top tier customer service and a genuinely great staff.
  • Alicia Pizza
    Trust them with ALL of my personal and business insurance.
  • Steven J. Lutz
    Highly recommended!
  • AG
    Their rates are great and they are easy to work with.
  • SN
    A Company that responded very quickly to my auto and home policies.

Independent Insurance Agency Advantage

As an Independent Agency serving the New Jersey community for over 75 years, Wagner Insurance has partnered with many top-tier national and regional carriers. These partnerships and years of experience allow Wagner Insurance to provide the proper coverage at the most competitive rates. Whether insuring a large commercial building or a smaller risk, be assured that the members of Wagner Insurance have the training and expertise to provide the proper coverage at a competitive price.

Questions? We Can Help!